Join jaguars.com senior editor Vic Ketchman as he tackles the fans' tough questions.
Joe from San Antonio, TX
I also watched that broadcast of Super Bowl XIII. The thing that I liked the most about it was that after every play they didn't need to put a stat on the screen. Watching football on television today is like VH1's “Pop-Up Video.” Which do you prefer?
Vic: The telecast of Super Bowl XIII was so bad it was good. What I mean by that is that is was easy viewing: know the score, watch the play. That was OK back then but today’s viewers are more sophisticated and need more “toys” to entertain them. I had no problem with no yellow line. I immediately resorted to my old way of locating the forward stick and knowing where the stripe would be. The replays were fine. They provided everything you needed to know whether the call was right or wrong. The replay of the Bennie Barnes’ pass-interference penalty, of course, was critical and TV was right on the spot. Even to this day, it’s a controversial play. The graphics TV displayed were laughable. That’s where the real advancement has been made. Curt Gowdy’s play-by-play call was masterful and Merlin Olsen and John Brodie weren’t as brash or technical with their analysis as today’s guys are, but they were right on most of the time and made a few observations you don’t hear today.
Mark from Panama City Beach, FL
Bradshaw and Staubach never turned to the refs looking for a flag. They got up, pulled themselves together and rallied their teams. Also, the flashiest thing I saw a player do was Lynn Swann waving his “Terrible Towel” during the introductions. Watching George Halas pat Jack Lambert on the back after the coin toss made me feel nostalgic. The only thing missing was the Joe Greene commercial giving that kid his jersey. Where were you that day in 1979?
Vic: I was right there in the press box. You mentioned the Halas-Lambert exchange; I love it. Halas arrived at midfield for the coin toss in an old-fashioned convertible, which was symbolic of the car dealership at which the league was created. After the coin toss, Lambert stopped at the car and shook Halas’ hand and the two of them appeared to have a rather lengthy and meaningful exchange. That’s what I call respect for the roots of the game.
Jacob from Weymouth, MA
“He was face-guarding. You’re not permitted to do that. It’s been that way forever. You can’t shadow a receiver for the purpose of blocking his vision of the ball. That’s what Hobbs was doing. It was an easy call.” Vic, you should check your NFL rules book. Face-guarding was made legal in the NFL six or seven years ago. Learn the rules before you make blatantly wrong claims.
Vic: I bow to your superior intellect. I checked out what you are saying and you are absolutely correct. Face-guarding was discontinued several years ago and I completely missed it. I talked to Dean Blandino in the league office and he confirmed what you’re saying. Blandino, by the way, was in the replay booth at the Patriots-Colts game. Ellis Hobbs should not have been flagged for pass-interference. He didn’t make contact with the receiver and in no way did Hobbs impede Reggie Wayne’s ability to catch the pass. Blandino confirmed that the incorrect call was made. It advanced the ball from the Patriots’ 19-yard line to the one-yard line and was the big play in a touchdown drive that led to a two-point conversion and a tie game at 21-21. Referee Bill Carollo made no reference to face-guarding in his explanation, but CBS analyst Phil Simms did. Apparently, he, too, doesn’t know the rule no longer exists. The next time you hear a TV analyst say, “he wasn’t playing the ball,” think of the Hobbs play, then turn down the sound.
Hemp from Jacksonville
I understand that Carson Palmer is unhappy about a number of his teammates getting arrested? If he is that unhappy and the Jaguars may be looking for a quarterback; what say you, Vic?
Vic: You’re living in a dream world.
John from Jacksonville
Do players receive game checks for playoff games or is there an equal pay grade based on stage of game in playoffs like the Super Bowl winners receive?
Vic: Players receive separate checks for all postseason games. The deeper you go into the playoffs, the more money you receive per game.
William from Jacksonville
Next week, the commissioner will deliver his first state-of-the-league address. As either an editorial or here, could we get Vic's state-of-the-league address?
Vic: As far as I’m concerned, there’s one issue that supersedes all others: What are the owners going to do about the league’s current failed business model? The current Collective Bargaining Agreement, combined with the lack of a revenue-sharing program, has put the owners and the players on a crash-course for confrontation in 2010. That’s going to be the state of the league between now and then.
Nick from Toronto, Ontario
How did offensive linemen block before 1978? If they couldn't use their hands, what was the most popular technique?
Vic: They blocked with their forearms. Prior to 1978, when the ball was snapped offensive linemen would grab the front of their jerseys with their hands and extend their forearms. At the same time they were grabbing their jerseys with their hands, the defensive linemen were hitting them on the helmet with a legal tactic known as the “head slap.” In the 1960’s, when the helmets had a metallic quality to them, a guy who was able to conceal a good plaster job under some tape could actually make an offensive lineman’s head ring like a bell with a strategically placed head slap just above the ear hole. Did you ever see the famous picture of Y.A. Tittle? A vicious defensive end named John Baker did that. By the way, if offensive linemen got their hands the least little bit away from their bodies, they’d get called for holding, and holding was a 15-yard penalty back then.
Vincent from Jacksonville
Don’t you think the rules changes were necessary to protect the players from a future of disability and extensive pain? I'm sure you know a litany of guys suffering from the brutality widespread before rules were implemented to protect the players.
Vic: Yes, the rules needed to be modified, to protect the players. The game had become unduly dangerous. Lynn Swann was targeted by the Raiders and was assaulted in a way that would make the jaws of today’s fans drop. It led to the infamous “criminal element” remark. The assault on wide receivers culminated in Daryl Stingley suffering a paralyzing hit in a preseason game. The violence of the ’70’s game is almost indescribable. The 1975 AFC title game was the real-life version of “The Longest Yard.”
Evan from Sioux Falls, SD
Did you really just suggest that Peyton Manning's skills are declining based on his playoff performance? I normally think you are on the mark, but here I would suggest you might be hoping a little too hard.
Vic: Yeah, and I got a lot of e-mails a couple of years ago from people who went crazy when I said Ray Lewis was in decline. Wadda ya think now?
Knox from St. Simons Island, GA
Fred Taylor talked about how he was going to go down to South Florida again this year to work out aside from the team, however, this year he is planning on bringing fellow teammates. Do you think him taking some teammates this year will be a good idea and maybe further condition other players to the level he was?
Vic: Why do I think this subject is going to come up in contract negotiations between Fred and the team?
Tim from Jacksonville
Yesterday you answered a question about a QB's vision; his ability to see the field and read defenses. You said it is a learned trait. Who among the current QB's on the Jags roster has mastered this trait, if any, in your opinion?
Vic: Seeing the field, in my opinion, is Byron Leftwich’s greatest strength. I think seeing the field is the thing David Garrard has to improve and, if he does, it could be the difference-maker in his career. I don’t know where Quinn Gray stands in this department.